Skip to content
Utah Says

What's the best pizza in Salt Lake City? ๐Ÿ•

Tap a choice to vote. Results appear right away.

New Be the first to vote

Salt Lake City only. Which pizzeria wins the capital?

About this vote

The statewide vote is one thing โ€” this one is just for Salt Lake City. Vote for your go-to pie in the capital.

All-time votes

0

This week

0

Asked

Oct 4, 2026

Current ranking ยท tap to view

No votes yet โ€” the first vote decides the early leader.

  1. โ€“The Pie PizzeriaLongtime University of Utah-area favorite.0% ยท 0
  2. โ€“Settebello Pizzeria NapoletanaWood-fired Neapolitan pizza.0% ยท 0
  3. โ€“Pizza NonoSalt Lake City neighborhood pizzeria.0% ยท 0
  4. โ€“Este PizzaNew York-style pizza in Salt Lake City.0% ยท 0
  5. โ€“Bricks CornerDetroit-style pizza in Salt Lake City.0% ยท 0

Are you one of the choices?

Get a share card for your fans: โ€œWe're #3 โ€” help us reach #1.โ€

Local Guide & Context

Best Pizza in Salt Lake City: Downtown & Neighborhood Pizzerias Ranked (2026)

This ballot is strictly for Salt Lake City. From underground college pies near the University of Utah to wood-fired Neapolitan and Detroit-style squares, here is what each SLC pizzeria is known for.

Salt Lake City Pizzerias on the Ballot

The Pie Pizzeria

University of Utah ยท Underground

Salt Lake City's iconic basement pizzeria near the U, famous for thick, cheese-loaded pies, pull-apart cheese bread, and wall-to-wall chalk signatures.

Settebello Pizzeria Napoletana

Downtown Salt Lake City

Authentic Vera Pizza Napoletana baked in a wood-fired oven with imported Italian ingredients and soft, blistered crusts.

Pizza Nono

9th and 9th Neighborhood

A beloved 9th & 9th neighborhood patio spot serving thin, wood-fired artisan pies with seasonal toppings.

Este Pizza

Sugar House & Downtown

Classic New York-style hand-tossed pizza by the slice or whole pie, known for garlic knots and vegan options.

Bricks Corner

South Salt Lake / Central

Detroit-style deep-dish square pizza baked in blue steel pans with crispy, caramelized Wisconsin brick cheese edges.

Salt Lake City Pizza Night Tips

Pick Your Crust Style

Go to Settebello or Pizza Nono for wood-fired Neapolitan, Este for foldable New York slices, Bricks Corner for crispy Detroit squares, or The Pie for thick, loaded college-style pizza.

Pre-Game Downtown Dining

Settebello in downtown SLC fills quickly before Delta Center games and concerts โ€” arrive early or head to 9th & 9th or Sugar House for neighborhood seating.

Salt Lake City Pizza Contenders at a Glance

Neighborhood, crust style, and signature order for each SLC pizzeria on the ballot
PizzeriaSLC NeighborhoodPizza Style & Signature Order
The Pie PizzeriaUniversity of Utah (Underground)Thick loaded hand-tossed pies & Mountain of Meat
Settebello Pizzeria NapoletanaDowntown SLC (200 West)Wood-fired Neapolitan Margherita & Diavola
Pizza Nono9th & 9thWood-fired neighborhood artisan thin-crust pies
Este PizzaSugar House / DowntownNew York-style foldable slices & garlic knots
Bricks CornerCentral / South Salt LakeDetroit-style pan pizza with caramelized cheese crust

Frequently Asked Questions

Which pizzerias are on the Best Pizza in Salt Lake City ballot?โ–ผ

The Salt Lake City pizza ballot includes The Pie Pizzeria, Settebello Pizzeria Napoletana, Pizza Nono, Este Pizza, and Bricks Corner. The live ranking updates in real time from real Utah Says votes.

Where can I get Neapolitan, New York, or Detroit-style pizza in Salt Lake City?โ–ผ

Settebello and Pizza Nono specialize in wood-fired Neapolitan-style pies, Este Pizza serves classic New York-style slices, Bricks Corner bakes Detroit-style square pan pizza, and The Pie Pizzeria is famous for thick, heavily topped college-style pies.

How does the Salt Lake City pizza poll differ from Best Pizza in Utah?โ–ผ

This ballot focuses specifically on Salt Lake City pizzerias, whereas Best Pizza in Utah tracks the broader statewide vote. You can cast a 1-tap vote in both polls.

Voted? Settle the SLC pizza night debate

Send this ballot to your dinner group before ordering and see which Salt Lake City pizzeria holds #1.

Embed this vote on your site

Run a blog or local business site? Paste this widget and your readers can open the vote with their pick highlighted. Results update when the widget loads.

Why Utah voted

Tell Utah why you picked what you picked. Keep it kind.

Sign in to join the conversation. Voting never needs an account.

No comments yet โ€” be the first to make your case.

Keep voting

You're all caught up. Got a question for Utah? Ask it!